Friday, July 31, 2015
Does Chinese Internet Censorship Really Work Out?
"According to the latest statistics from China Internet Network Information Center (CNNIC), an administrative body under the Ministry of Information Industry, China currently has 618 million Internet users and 281 million use popular microblogging sites known collectively as Weibo" (Ng, 2014). "In a 2013 study of social media site Sina Weibo, researchers at Northeastern University found empirical evidence that censorship sometimes not only fails to quash discussion of sensitive topics on Chinese social media sites, but may even encourage it. Though numerous factors may be at play, the finding reinforces the popular notion that attempts to conceal information can backfire and even become a central part of a story—a phenomenon known as the Streisand Effect" (Ng, 2014). According to Ng (2014), "one should not underestimate the ability of Chinese Internet users to dig up information authorities are trying to hide—especially when it directly affects them or when it relates to righting injustices. But one must also acknowledge that China’s censors often still have the will and the tools to manage online information effectively to suit the government’s need".
So it is clear that even though CNNIC wants to censor voices on social media, it seems not to work out sometimes. According to my own experiences, online discussions about information which is hided by authorities are always quickly missing in one day. I know clearly that CNNIC sometimes work very efficiently to censor contents online to avoid the harm to the public. The well-known great wall prevents us from using Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and google services to make sure that CNNIC is able to control our voices and speaking. However, we have already managed to have access to Facebook, Twitter, or Youtube in some ways. Even though some authorities are hiding information, several days later, or months later, the information came out eventually. As an old saying goes, “The best way to hide a misdeed is not to commit it".
In a nutshell, Chinese Internet censorship seems to work out sometimes, but it does not eventually due to the Chinese people' pursuit of the truth.
References
Ng, J.Q. (2014, March 17). How Chinese Internet Censorship Works, Sometimes. ChinaFile. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/03/17/china-internet-censorship_n_4981389.html
The Merits and Risks of Using Twitter for Professional Learning and Relationship Building?
Recently, I came up on two many conversations about the application of Twitter to support students' professional learning and language learning. So I want to explore more about the merits and risks of using Twitter for the two purposes.
As Dennen (2011) found, Twitter could be used to seek specific information about conference, and promote talks about all kinds of stuff about the conference thus enabling professional learning beyond the conference room. However, they found the potential downside of the application of Twitter was the sporadic and at times cryptic posting of useful information make people who did not take the conference at a lost and had no clues about what was going on. I think one reason is that Twitter has the limitation of 140 words. 140 words make most of tweets lose the background information. Dennen (2011) also found that people from different fields might post different types and number of tweets. For those fields like computer science, information studies, most people are early adopters of Twitter technology. I think different stages of adoption of technology greatly affect people engagement in Twitter-based professional discourse. Another downside of the application of Twitter interaction is that a large percentage of tweets are replies and retweets instead of constructive replies because most participants are not familiar with each other.
By summarizing Dennen (2011)'s study, we can see that Twitter can support us to engage in professional conversations with followers under a certain hashtag. However, the limitation in words make it not easy to pass complete thoughts or ideas to others by tweets. Also, for some people, they are not getting used to the application of Twitter on academic or profession purpose. Another downside of twitter is that when followers for a hashtag are not familiar with each other, they do not often engage in deep conversations with others.
Taking my own experience in the course for example. At the beginning, I actively engaged in Twitter because I had something to share with. During these two weeks, I kind of left behind the twitter conversations because I did not have time to check updated tweets and share my ideas. I guess the time is also a big factor affecting students' engagement in Twitter-based conversations.
You can also go to this website, and check the pros and cons of Using Twitter. http://www.grosocial.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-twitter/ I echoed with the following point.
I remember Michelle posted a question in discussion board: would it be better to use email instead than Twitter when we engage in a quite daily-life conversation with one person? I totally agree. Most of us have been used to sending email at a fingertip. Why do we bother using Twitter when we want to talk about kind of private life or topic with others.?
All in all, I think we should think thoroughly about using Twitter to support professional learning.
As Dennen (2011) found, Twitter could be used to seek specific information about conference, and promote talks about all kinds of stuff about the conference thus enabling professional learning beyond the conference room. However, they found the potential downside of the application of Twitter was the sporadic and at times cryptic posting of useful information make people who did not take the conference at a lost and had no clues about what was going on. I think one reason is that Twitter has the limitation of 140 words. 140 words make most of tweets lose the background information. Dennen (2011) also found that people from different fields might post different types and number of tweets. For those fields like computer science, information studies, most people are early adopters of Twitter technology. I think different stages of adoption of technology greatly affect people engagement in Twitter-based professional discourse. Another downside of the application of Twitter interaction is that a large percentage of tweets are replies and retweets instead of constructive replies because most participants are not familiar with each other.
By summarizing Dennen (2011)'s study, we can see that Twitter can support us to engage in professional conversations with followers under a certain hashtag. However, the limitation in words make it not easy to pass complete thoughts or ideas to others by tweets. Also, for some people, they are not getting used to the application of Twitter on academic or profession purpose. Another downside of twitter is that when followers for a hashtag are not familiar with each other, they do not often engage in deep conversations with others.
Taking my own experience in the course for example. At the beginning, I actively engaged in Twitter because I had something to share with. During these two weeks, I kind of left behind the twitter conversations because I did not have time to check updated tweets and share my ideas. I guess the time is also a big factor affecting students' engagement in Twitter-based conversations.
You can also go to this website, and check the pros and cons of Using Twitter. http://www.grosocial.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-twitter/ I echoed with the following point.
- Twitter is busy. Twitter users generate 340 million tweets per day, and most users follow several hundred profiles. Because there is no Edgerank, if you only tweet once or twice a day, your tweets are quickly buried in your followers’ feeds.
I remember Michelle posted a question in discussion board: would it be better to use email instead than Twitter when we engage in a quite daily-life conversation with one person? I totally agree. Most of us have been used to sending email at a fingertip. Why do we bother using Twitter when we want to talk about kind of private life or topic with others.?
All in all, I think we should think thoroughly about using Twitter to support professional learning.
Wednesday, July 29, 2015
What types of reflection do we need? Group reflection, instructor-supported reflection, and self-reflection?
Since the readings in this week are my interest, I would
like to reflect on those readings. According to Kim, Hong, Bonk, and Lim
(2011)'s experimental study, instructor-supported reflection led to better
performance, and team effectiveness. Their result was consistent with previous
studies. Based on my experiences, I think that makes lots of sense. A group
members could not build a mutual trust during a short time period, and thus
need instructors' feedback. Instructors should monitor and take part in
their learning process, make suggestions, references, or resources related to
their project to learners, replies to student emails, and grade work with
comments. Teachers' feedback let students feel that they are not alone. Even
though team members do not collaborate very well with each other, they can hang
there with teachers' guidance or even interventions.
Regarding group reflection, the study showed that actually
team effectiveness was improved towards the ending of the experiment. This also
made sense. At the beginning of the teamwork, members may not be familiar with each
other. Thus they do not know how to interact with each other, and what words
should be used. You know, individuals have different preferences. For example,
my preference is that I am almost offline at weekends, and choosing reading
articles and papers. However, in one team project I was working on, my team
members still worked at weekends because of the deadline. So I did not respond
to them immediately via email. As I think back, I feel sorry for them. But I
indeed actively participate in the group project. But I can feel they feel not
so safe when failing in receiving my email immediately. So when working in a
team, knowing individual preferences in the schedule, learning characteristic
is very important. As time goes by, team
members can gradually know better about each other. At this point, they can collaborate
with each other more smoothly. As Kim et al. (2011) found, team members felt a
burden when critically evaluating others’ performance. But I think if every
member in a team try their best to make contributions to the team work, they
won’t feel awkward at all. I remember I made good friends with my team members
in a team project. We actually kept weekly meeting even after the class
project. When giving peer feedback, I did not feel nervous at all because they
were all great team members.
As self-reflection is concerned, I think it is hard to do,
but more deeply. Even though the study did not reveal the importance of
self-reflection, I do think it is very helpful to improve our critical thinking
and knowledge base. Personally speaking, knowledge can only be taken after the
application and reflection. For example, after I read the article, I could not
connect the knowledge and studies with my previous knowledge base and cognition
until I made reflections on it in this blog. Also, I like reading others’ deep
reflection blog, which make me learn about unfamiliar topics and experiences. I
think individuals have their own wisdom and ways of thinking. We can always
learn from others’ deep reflection on their experiences or perceptions.
The above are my thoughts. Look forward to your
feedback. Lol.
Kim, P., Hong, J., Bonk, C., & Lim, G (2011): Effects of
group reflection variations in project-based learning integrated in a Web 2.0
learning space, Interactive Learning
Environments, 19(4), 333-349. doi:10.1080/10494820903210782
How’s CampusPress different than Edublogs?
Refer to this webpage: http://edublogs.org/2014/03/04/campuspress-wordpress-for-education/
Different from edublog, the CampusPress is dedicated network for schools & universities! Schools and universities need to pay for it.
There are two better features provided by CampusPress are as follows:- a dedicated WordPress Multisite network at a branded domain, like sites.myschool.edu
- unlimited sites, users, traffic, and storage
With the two features, every school, department, and program can create their own pages where students and teachers can share news, valuable resources, and engage in conversations with educators from all over the world.
By exploring more on the CampusPress, I find that as super administrator, you can enable Google Analytics to track visitor data across all of the blogs in your CampusPress network. This is very powerful. You can check it out via http://www.campuspress.com/docs/general-settings/creating-a-network-google-analytics-account/
How can we use Twitter to support a community of practice (CoP) changing practice?
To be honest, I think a CoP is necessary condition for professional
learning and knowledge growth. CoP
refers to the relations between community members: mutual engagement, a shared
repertoire and joint enterprise (Wenger, 1998). As the definition suggest, in a
CoP, members often engage in sharing their knowledge, understanding, and ideas
to achieve a common goal. Based on my
personal experience, I think engaging in a community of practice is a perfect
way to improve our knowledge and skills. I still remember how little I know
about the research, work ethics, study norms, and life in this program. By
engaging in all kinds of social events, research mix, research team meeting with
other students in one research group, and group projects, I grow my knowledge
about the research, work ethics, study norms, and life in this program, and
then my love in this program. Now I know very well who share the same or
similar research interest with me, who have a different interest, and what
scholar practices I need to participate in. For example, I know I should try to
present my paper at AECT or AERA, or other related conference, and then write and
publish my paper.
Speaking of the application of social media in supporting
CoP, I am thinking about integrating necessary social media tools to support my
CoP in a specific research group. Of
course, Twitter, Facebook, Diigo, and Youtube would be included.
Social media like Twitter can offer a virtual space for
improving our knowledge, skills, and practices in a community. As Goodyear, Casey
and Kirk 2014) found, the tweets, RTs and likes could reinforce teachers’ good
changing practice by passing a message “you are doing the right thing”, which
developing the trust between members. I think the trust built on those tweets,
RTs and likes was more important. Since community members trust in other members,
they felt comfortable in sharing their feelings, attitudes, knowledge and real
practices. With trust, community members felt that their tweets were valued,
meaningful to others. Thus, they would rather share more about themselves and
practices by Twitter.
For some members who were very active, they portrayed
themselves in a new identity as star performers (Goodyear, Casey & Kirk 2014),
thus promoting their engagement in Twitter-based communication. For these
members, they were motivated by their high self-efficacy. When they felt
confident in doing something, they would rather continuing doing that. Also, it is important to have a leader in Twitter-based
communication. In the study case, Vitoria
played a big role in answering members’ questions, modeling twitter-based
communication and good practices, promoting the communication between members
by retweeting, likes and encouraging face-to-face talk without her. Even though
Victoria as a leader for the Twitter-based conversation, she was just a
facilitator for a project for a short time. The engagement of the real leader
in the department was more important. By creating an account to support
teachers’ changing practice, the real leader passed a message “we are together
doing something right”. This eventually
signifying the CoP in a Twitter environment. I think, at this point, Twitter
was not a simple communication tool. Instead, it was an online CoP.
Goodyear, V. A., Casey, A., & Kirk, D. (2014): Tweet me,
message me, like me: using social media to facilitate pedagogical change within
an emerging community of practice, Sport,
Education and Society, 19(7),
927-943. doi: 10.1080/13573322.2013.858624
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice; learning, meaning and identity. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Monday, July 27, 2015
Quora: a collection of questions and answers. I like it!
Thank our teacher for sharing this tool: http://www.quora.com/
I think this quora tool is a good one to help us to find
answers we want. I have already
registered for this website, and chose all the topics that I am interested.
Personally speaking, I think nowadays, proposing a valuable question is even
more important than answering a question. You know, before we extend our
knowledge by exploring more resources, we do not even know what we do not know.
The more you learn, the more you realize how little you know. So it’s good of Quora to offer a platform to collect
all questions in various areas. For example, I chose the topic about education
and technology. I am wondering what questions others hold about these two
questions. Another thing attract me of
this tool is that I can see how they express their questions related to some
topics I am interested. Quora makes sure
that all the questions are of quality. Otherwise, it won’t take it. That’s a
blessing for me. My written English is not good enough. I need to learn from
others about how I can express my ideas and thoughts appropriately. Also, I can
learn a lot from answers from professionals. On this website, it also allows you to rate the questions and answers. The rating would help people to identify which questions are valuable and most popular.
In the near future, I will explore lots of questions related
to my interest: online learning in Quora. I highly recommend you explore this
tool, and share with me about your feelings.
The following is a screenshot of what I got when searched for a topic about MOOCs. I found lots of valuable resources.
After going through this question, I would clear know what questions are most proposed regarding MOOCs.
Sunday, July 26, 2015
What guidance should be given to students for their web 2.0 assignments?
Gray et al (2012) found teachers have encountered too main challenges towards assessment of web 2.0 assignments. In the last blog post, I mainly discussed about the second challenge: how to evaluate students' evaluation. In this blog, I will focus on what guidance students should receive for the Web 2.0 assignments.
What guidance should be given to students for their web 2.0 assignments?
Teachers are worried about that what guidance they should offer students. They are worried that too much guidance would put constraints on students' thinking. But inadequate guidance may let students get lost and feel frustrated (Gray et al, 2012). I think they should work together with their tutors, or assistants to give clear guidance for students during the whole process of web 2.0 assignments.
Before they work on the assignments, teachers need to offer clear criteria for the web 2.0 assignments. and also prepare students for a new form of assignments.
As with the criteria, different levels of study, and potential diverse content types make it hard to establish a clear and fixed criteria (Gray et al, 2012). But I think it is necessary and doable to offer clear criteria for web 2.0 assignments. Take one assignment based on blogger for example. In the criteria, teachers can make it clear that students need to finish the minimum requirement: writing at least 4 blogs reflecting on what we have learned in this weekin a week (borrowing ideas from V), making at least 4 comments on classmates, reading at least 8 blogs. As long as they finish the minimum requirement, they feel free to post more blogs. I think the minimum requirement works effectively in web 2.0 assignments and traditional assignments. Students always need to know what they should finish. I know web 2.0 tools should enable students to express freely. But as long as they are applied in educational environments, clear learning objectives should be attached to the assignments, I believe.
They should also inform students of that they may go through a different process with web 2.0 technologies if some students are not used to web 2.0 assignments. As Gray et al (2012) found, students need to know they may not do well in the web 2.0 assignments at first. Students need to know that they may gradually find their unique voices, and understand the rules for sharing appropriately and writing with authority. Teachers also need to inform students that their process for doing their assignments would be assessed. As long as students know about that, they will purposely keep notes of their contributions to the assignments. Take Wiki-based collective assignments for example. Students need to know they should not directly overwrite others' input. Instead, they should leave a comment to others' editing. After two students agree on rewriting some sentences, they can do that. But they should make notes of that. This will make it easier for teachers to evaluate students' different contributions to the Wiki assignments. However, Students not only demonstrate learning outcomes in a discipline, but also facilitate their learning processes in web 2.0 assignments (Gray et al, 2012). They facilitated their learning processes by optimizing peer review, extending the learning community, encouraging ongoing engagement (Gray et al, 2012). So to be fair, teachers should make clear about how they assign grades to individuals' contributions to facilitating the learning process. Let's imagine this situation: a student always lead the wiki writing, and leave positive comment and feedback to others' writing. His contribution needs definitely to be marked to encourage students to make such contributions.
Reference:
What guidance should be given to students for their web 2.0 assignments?
Teachers are worried about that what guidance they should offer students. They are worried that too much guidance would put constraints on students' thinking. But inadequate guidance may let students get lost and feel frustrated (Gray et al, 2012). I think they should work together with their tutors, or assistants to give clear guidance for students during the whole process of web 2.0 assignments.
Before they work on the assignments, teachers need to offer clear criteria for the web 2.0 assignments. and also prepare students for a new form of assignments.
As with the criteria, different levels of study, and potential diverse content types make it hard to establish a clear and fixed criteria (Gray et al, 2012). But I think it is necessary and doable to offer clear criteria for web 2.0 assignments. Take one assignment based on blogger for example. In the criteria, teachers can make it clear that students need to finish the minimum requirement: writing at least 4 blogs reflecting on what we have learned in this weekin a week (borrowing ideas from V), making at least 4 comments on classmates, reading at least 8 blogs. As long as they finish the minimum requirement, they feel free to post more blogs. I think the minimum requirement works effectively in web 2.0 assignments and traditional assignments. Students always need to know what they should finish. I know web 2.0 tools should enable students to express freely. But as long as they are applied in educational environments, clear learning objectives should be attached to the assignments, I believe.
They should also inform students of that they may go through a different process with web 2.0 technologies if some students are not used to web 2.0 assignments. As Gray et al (2012) found, students need to know they may not do well in the web 2.0 assignments at first. Students need to know that they may gradually find their unique voices, and understand the rules for sharing appropriately and writing with authority. Teachers also need to inform students that their process for doing their assignments would be assessed. As long as students know about that, they will purposely keep notes of their contributions to the assignments. Take Wiki-based collective assignments for example. Students need to know they should not directly overwrite others' input. Instead, they should leave a comment to others' editing. After two students agree on rewriting some sentences, they can do that. But they should make notes of that. This will make it easier for teachers to evaluate students' different contributions to the Wiki assignments. However, Students not only demonstrate learning outcomes in a discipline, but also facilitate their learning processes in web 2.0 assignments (Gray et al, 2012). They facilitated their learning processes by optimizing peer review, extending the learning community, encouraging ongoing engagement (Gray et al, 2012). So to be fair, teachers should make clear about how they assign grades to individuals' contributions to facilitating the learning process. Let's imagine this situation: a student always lead the wiki writing, and leave positive comment and feedback to others' writing. His contribution needs definitely to be marked to encourage students to make such contributions.
Reference:
Gray, K., Waycott, J., Clerehan, R., Hamilton,
M., Richardson, J., Sheard, J., & Thompson, C. (2012). Worth it? Findings
from a study of how academics assess students. Research in Learning Technology
2012, 2, 21-35- doi:
10.3402/rlt.v20i0/16153
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
